Mutual Funds vs. Stocks: The Complete Guide

When it comes to building your portfolio, mutual funds vs. stocks is one of the biggest decisions you’ll make. Both options can help you grow your money, but they work in different ways and come with their own pros and cons.

The right choice depends on things like your goals, how much risk you’re comfortable with, and how hands-on you want to be with your investments. This guide breaks down everything you need to know to help you make the best decision for your situation.

Mutual Funds vs. Stocks: What’s the Difference?

In the simplest terms, a stock represents ownership in a single company. If you buy a share of stock, you own a tiny fraction of that company.

As the company grows and earns profits, the stock price may rise, and you can sell your shares for more than you paid. Stocks can also pay dividends, which are periodic payments, if the company shares profits with shareholders.

A mutual fund, on the other hand, is a pooled investment. Many investors put money into the fund, and a professional fund manager uses that money to buy a diversified mix of securities. These might include dozens or hundreds of stocks, bonds, or other assets. By owning one share of a mutual fund, you own a tiny part of all the fund’s holdings.

Mutual funds come in different styles; some aim to match a market index (passive funds), while others are actively managed to try to beat the market. Mutual funds price their shares once per day (based on net asset value), and investors buy or sell at that daily price.

Both mutual funds and stocks are ways to invest in the stock market and seek long-term growth. Stocks give you direct control of which companies you own, while mutual funds give you instant diversification and professional management. In practice, many investors use both in their portfolios.

Here are some mutual funds vs. stocks differences:

Diversification

Diversification means spreading your money across many investments to reduce risk. This is a key benefit of mutual funds. Because a mutual fund holds a basket of assets, your investment isn’t tied to one stock’s success. Even buying a diversified fund of just U.S. large-cap stocks gives you exposure to hundreds of companies at once.

In contrast, buying a single stock concentrates your investment in one company. If that company struggles, your investment can lose a lot of value. To get the same kind of protection mutual funds offer, you’d need to buy shares in many different companies, which can be hard and expensive, especially if you’re just starting out.

Risk Tolerance

Your risk tolerance, which essentially means how much risk you can accept, can help decide between mutual funds vs. stocks.

Typically, individual stocks are higher risk than mutual funds and tend to be more volatile. If a single company has trouble, its stock could plunge and take your investment with it. Funds, on the other hand, tend to spread risk: losses in one holding may be offset by gains or stability in others.

Most mutual funds target consistent, long-term growth with less volatility than the market as a whole. In other words, funds often underperform the market during big bull runs but lose less in down markets.

Many advisors recommend a balanced approach, combining low-cost index funds with a few chosen stocks if you enjoy that. That way, you get the growth potential of stocks and the stability of funds.

The best choice depends on your goals, timeline, and comfort with volatility. For example, a young investor saving for retirement might lean heavily on diversified funds to ride out market cycles, then gradually introduce stocks once they better understand the market.

Active vs. Passive Management

Another difference is how much you or others manage the investment. When you buy a stock, you choose the company yourself or trust your broker to do so. Mutual funds hire managers to select investments.

Some funds use active management, where managers carefully pick stocks in an effort to beat the market. Others follow a passive investing approach — these are index funds that simply track a market index, aiming to match its performance rather than outperform it.

Active funds charge higher fees and often underperform passive ones over time. Passive funds like S&P 500 index funds aim to match market returns with very low costs.

In contrast, investing in individual stocks means you make all decisions — or follow your own research and trading strategy — without any management fee, aside from trading costs.

Costs and Fees

When you trade stocks, brokers can charge a commission per trade. The good news is that many online brokers now offer $0 commissions on U.S. stock trades. This means buying and selling stocks can cost nothing in commission fees today.

However, brokers may still charge other fees, like account or service fees, and some smaller brokers might charge a small fee per trade. For this reason, you should always check the brokerage’s fee schedule.

Mutual funds, on the other hand, typically charge an expense ratio: an annual percentage of your investment that pays for running the fund. Actively managed funds often have higher expense ratios, which can sometimes be above 1% per year, while passive index funds usually charge much less, often well below 0.2%.

Some mutual funds also charge loads, which are one-time sales fees when you buy or sell shares. Front-end loads (on purchase) and back-end loads (on sale) have become less common, but they do exist on certain funds.

Long-Term Growth Potential

Both stocks and mutual funds offer long-term growth potential, but with different profiles. Historically, broad U.S. stock market indexes, like the S&P 500, have returned about 10% per year on average.

This growth can compound over decades. Buying a broad-market index fund provides exposure to this growth trend with the added benefit of built-in diversification. Many mutual funds are aimed at long-term investing, where you’re seeking smooth, consistent growth.

In boom years, an index fund will rise in line with the market; in downturns, it will drop, but often less than a single volatile stock might. Remember, past performance is no guarantee, and all investments can lose value.

But over a long time horizon, broad stock exposure through stocks or funds has historically grown investors’ wealth.

Portfolio Management Tips for Beginners

When it comes to mutual funds vs. stocks, choosing the right investment is only part of the equation. Building a healthy, balanced portfolio is just as important. Here are some practical portfolio management tips to help keep your investments on the right track:

Set Clear Goals

Decide why you’re investing. Is it retirement decades away? Will you need a house down payment in five years? Different goals mean different strategies. Longer goals (10+ years) can usually tolerate more risk for higher growth, while shorter goals may require safer investments like bonds or money markets.

Know Your Risk Tolerance

Be honest about how much volatility you can stomach. Are you comfortable seeing your portfolio drop 20% in a market correction, or would that cause panic? Your risk profile (conservative, moderate, aggressive) should guide how you mix stocks, funds, and bonds.

Rebalance Periodically

Over time, some holdings may grow faster than others, skewing your original mix. Check your portfolio at least once a year. If the stock portion has grown too much, you might sell some stocks and buy bonds, or vice versa, to reset your target allocation. This “buy low, sell high” discipline can improve long-term outcomes.

Invest Confidently With Gorilla Trades

Gorilla Trades uses powerful, proven technology to spot top stock opportunities in any kind of market. It gives you clear, easy-to-understand guidance with smart picks based on real data. As a member, you’ll get access to exclusive tools and resources designed to help you grow your portfolio and make better investing decisions.

If you want to see how it works, you can try it free for 30 days.