Lance Hammer was the toast of the city in 2008 along with his hard-hitting, Mississippi-set coming-of-age drama “Ballast.” The Dardennes-esque vérité portrait of lives careening from loss and financial hardship received two awards on the Sundance Movie Competition that 12 months — together with Greatest Director for Hammer — and acquired a number of Movie Impartial Spirit and Gotham award nominations.
After which, poof: Hammer was by no means heard from once more.
He has now returned, nearly 20 years later, with an especially upsetting however compassionate ethical drama about company amid dementia, titled “Queen at Sea.” It stars Juliette Binoche as a girl determined and panicked to care for her ailing mom, Leslie (Anna Calder-Marshall, completely shattering in her specificity towards the illness’ toll), who’s slipping deeper into the sickness. Leslie’s grasp of time, reminiscence, and performance is vanishing within the multi-story London flat she shares together with her husband of 19 years, Martin (a brutally heartbreaking Tom Courtenay). In the meantime, Amanda (Binoche), an educational on sabbatical, goes by way of a separation herself — from her husband in Newcastle, and now she’s compelled to deliver her daughter, Sara (Florence Hunt), together with her again to London to examine in on her mom.
However when Amanda catches her stepfather, Martin, in a compromising place with Leslie, one other separation units into movement, with Leslie doubtlessly about to be misplaced in an elder-care system that’s horrifying and scary for the affected person, and a sort of emotional dying sentence for her and her family members.
As somebody who’s watched an in depth cherished one lose themselves to Alzheimer’s illness, I discovered “Queen at Sea” to be particularly bruising, even regardless of a few of its patchier plot notes. The feelings are there, even when the story is, nicely, misplaced at sea at occasions. The geographical configuration surrounding Amanda, having left behind a husband (and Sara’s father) in Newcastle, is complicated. In the meantime, Sara has in a short time restarted her life in Newcastle with new pals and a possible new flame, as author/director Hammer attracts parallel comparisons within the edit between Sara’s blooming relationship with a classmate, and Leslie’s psychological deterioration and estrangement from her personal companion.
When the film begins, Amanda is on a home name to examine on Leslie, and walks in on Martin trying to have intercourse with a dazed-out, addled-eyed Leslie prostrate on the mattress. This isn’t the primary time this has occurred, and it’s an prevalence Amanda has implored Martin to knock off. However the Viagra in his medication cupboard suggests in any other case, that he retains going again for extra, that Amanda retains asking him to cease.
Dementia dramas like Sarah Polley’s wounding “Away from Her” (whereby Julie Christie’s husband Grant Anderson mainly units her up in a nursing house to counteract his personal infidelities) and Michael Haneke’s Oscar-winning “Amour” (the harshest of this fleet of movies) are inclined to heart close-up on the relations between an Alzheimer’s affected person and her companion, and the way these relationships break down when there are fewer previous and current recollections to discovered them on.
Hammer’s movie introduces profound new questions and points about consent into the method — is Leslie agreeing on some stage to have intercourse together with her husband? Is the one pleasure in her winnowing life to be denied? Can an individual with dementia consent to having intercourse? Leslie’s instincts now are narrowed to the primal: meals, water, sleep, and, naturally, intercourse. So the place do all these leftover emotions go when the physique containing them is now solely a vessel for a going thoughts?
Martin insists that Leslie — a once-celebrated and really gifted painter now slowly going mute, mentally and emotionally and bodily — is having fun with these encounters. They’ve been married for 19 years, in any case, and when Amanda calls the police and introduces authorities into the scenario, the couple is immediately torn asunder. Then come up questions on whether or not they need to proceed to be separated and whether or not to position Leslie in a house.
Which is ultimately what occurs, and the place Leslie types an inappropriate bond with one other affected person to fill the Martin void. Author/director Hammer, although, downplays the melodrama inherent to this situation, even whereas taking pictures sequences, whether or not in Martin and Leslie’s house or in varied hospitals, with a bracing handheld intimacy. (Cinematographer Adolpho Veloso, in the meantime, bathes London in a fantastically pale daylight.) Removed from sterilely composed, a rape equipment examination compelled upon Leslie is harrowing and demeaning, particularly as she has no thought what’s happening and no clue why a speculum is being inserted into her. In what world may Martin have raped his spouse?
Binoche, who has been giving dedicated and emotionally managed performances for years currently, together with in movies by Hanekeoffers certainly one of her most unsentimental and gripping performances at this stage in her profession in “Queen at Sea.” An emotional cellphone name to her soon-to-be ex-husband lays naked to blanched vulnerability as she dials the final individual she would favor to not name, however the one she is compelled to anyway. Inside lives outdoors these decided by this case could also be missing, however Leslie’s isn’t. Amanda’s mom appears to activate when given the prospect to color at a nursing house, an aseptic and horrible place for which everybody within the household appears to be awkwardly auditioning.
The good British actor Courtenay, most lately memorable within the equally memory-impaired marriage portrait “45 Years” reverse Charlotte Rampling, is sort of devastating as a husband scrambling for solutions and to legitimize his personal place in Leslie’s life. The one factor that doesn’t fairly land, and appears fairly actually chopped into the movie, is Florence Hunt as Amanda’s daughter. Hammer appears to be making an attempt to sign that she could also be headed for her personal future psychological wreck by intercutting her first romance with scenes of Martin and Leslie’s final. It’s a noble thought, nevertheless it finally ends up feeling like scraps from an earlier draft.
Finally, although, anybody who’s endured what Amanda, or Leslie, or Martin do on this film will discover one thing to narrate to and really feel towards. Hammer spares no exhausting truths and provides no pat emotions with regard to how these persons are sure to finish up and what dementia in the end does to them. Let’s simply say hope is at a scarcity. However the actors assist carry Hammer’s message — and make it unforgettable.
Grade: B+
“Queen at Sea” premiered on the 2026 Berlin Movie Competition. It’s at present searching for U.S. distribution.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie opinions and important ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Evaluate by David Ehrlich, during which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Critiques Editor rounds up the most effective new opinions and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely accessible to subscribers.