A fifth grade instructor accused on-line of being a possible suspect within the Nancy Guthrie investigation is talking out after his home was swarmed by novice sleuths.
Dominic Evans48, advised The New York Instances in an interview on Wednesday, February 25, that his residence in Tucson, Arizona, was focused after the FBI launched surveillance digital camera photographs on February 10 of a masked man outdoors of Nancy’s residence north of Tucson. The armed particular person appeared to tamper with Nancy’s doorbell digital camera in footage and photographs recovered by the FBI.
Dominic advised the outlet that he has solely met Nancy, 84, as soon as, in 2011, and was falsely accused, partially, as a result of he’s in a band with Tommaso CioniNancy’s son-in-law and At present present cohost Savannah Guthrie’s brother-in-law. (Tommaso is married to Savannah’s sister, Annie.)
“I really feel like somebody’s taken my identify,” Dominic mentioned. “I don’t know (for what motive) — financial, clickbait, to be related, leisure — however there are harmless folks that get harm.”
Annie Guthrie and her household have discovered themselves within the highlight for a motive no one desires to expertise. On February 1, 2026, information broke that Nancy Guthrie was reported lacking in Arizona after a member of the family known as 911. Within the days that adopted, Annie and her siblings, who embrace Camron Guthrie and At present present anchor (…)
Dominic and his spouse, Andreaadvised the outlet that after the FBI photographs have been launched, his facial options have been in contrast to the masked particular person within the surveillance footage. Individuals on-line additionally introduced up a previous drunk-driving conviction and an arrest for a 1999 bar theft as additional proof of his involvement.
The couple mentioned they have been too scared to select up their two youngest youngsters from their grandmother’s home on the day the images have been launched due to the sheer variety of folks that had congregated outdoors of their residence.
“It was all evening trying by means of the window, attempting to not let any mild out of our residence,” Andrea mentioned, noting that she was “scared numb” by all of it.
Days later, after native police and the FBI coordinated a February 13 residence search and visitors cease in Tucson, extra individuals swarmed to the Evans’ residence, they mentioned. (The police detained and later launched 4 individuals in reference to a search warrant executed on February 13.)
The seek for Savannah Guthrie’s mother, Nancy Guthrie, has resulted in a brand new idea surrounding Mexico. Almost three weeks after Nancy was final seen alive in Tucson, Arizona, some crime watchers have speculated that the 84-year-old may have discovered herself in Mexico after being kidnapped from her residence. Whereas the Pima County Sheriff’s Workplace isn’t (…)
“This one felt actually, actually, actually scary, as a result of it was like everybody was ready for somebody to come back to our home,” Andrea mentioned.
Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanoswho’s main the seek for Nancy with the FBI, advised the New York Instances that he felt sorry for Dominic. The instructor spoke solely as soon as to investigators and had not heard from them since, the Instances reported.
“He’s going by means of hell, and it’s horrible,” Nanos mentioned. “And I don’t know what to inform him besides he most likely ought to be talking with some attorneys and sue a few of these individuals for libel.”
“I want I may soar out and defend each single one in all them that’s been falsely accused,” Nanos added.
The Pima County Sheriff’s Division has not publicly dominated out anybody in its investigation with the exception of Nancy’s speedy householdtogether with her son-in-law, who himself confronted scrutiny after an unverified report that he was a particular person of curiosity early on within the investigation.
“To be clear … the Guthrie household — to incorporate all siblings and spouses — have been cleared as potential suspects on this case. The household has been nothing however cooperative and gracious and are victims on this case,” Nanos mentioned in a press release on February 16.
Nanos added, “To recommend in any other case isn’t solely improper, it’s merciless. The Guthrie household are victims, plain and easy.”
On Tuesday, February 24, Savannah and her siblings elevated a financial reward for Nancy’s return to $1 million because the seek for the Guthrie matriarch nears the tip of its fourth week.