It’s robust being a Bram Stoker’s “Dracula” lady in a Robert Eggers’ “Nosferatu” world. However not even an additional campy Caleb Landry Jones — wearing a vampire get-up that makes him appear to be albino Jar Jar Binks — could make the newest retelling of the basic gothic novel really feel warranted or recent. Launched by Vertical on February 6 within the U.S., filmmaker Luc Besson‘s new tackle the darkly romantic horror story is a narratively tedious and contrived story that drains from its auteur’s visually lush craft.
The man behind sci-fi favourite “The Fifth Aspect” as soon as once more pronounces himself as a connoisseur of shiny colours and vaguely goofy fantasy ideas; right here, by overwhelming scenes taken from a larger-than-life model of Nineteenth-century Paris. A world this ornate ought to really feel equally immersive in its storytelling, however as a screenwriter, Besson will get immediately caught up over-explaining his plot in a way that means he might have confused literary density for honest emotion and top-shelf prose.
Opening 400 years earlier, Besson’s “Dracula” begins with the not-yet-undead Prince Vladimir of Wallachia (Jones) going to conflict — after a sensuous morning spent in mattress along with his Princess Elisabeta (Zoë Bleu). It’s not each remake you get a gothic romance the place the leads really like one another, and even fewer the place they’re straight. Photographs of the couple making love and stuffing meals into one another’s mouths arrives earlier than the rest. Nonetheless, underpinning their fiery reference to a palpable fondness, Besson’s route of “Dracula” can’t drum up the soul missing from such a weirdly stiff script
When Elisabeta is murdered throughout a battle with the Ottoman Empire, her widowed prince vows to change into a vampire and takes up the identify of Dracula, promising to sometime reunite along with his love. It’s a good plan that Besson stretches far past the chilly open he ought to’ve tried to as an alternative insert apparent insecurity by dialogue that routinely repeat itself. The unceremonious skewering of a non secular chief by an enraged Dracula is not any exception there, and the scene feels oddly torturous not as a result of it’s too violent — however as a result of the kill is uninteresting and ready for it isn’t happy sufficient by the ultimate knife’s twist.
From there, audiences are thrust again to France in 1889, the place Dracula units concerning the arduous process of carving out a particular area of interest in overly drained literary adaptation historical past. The similarities between 2024’s “Nosferatu” and Besson’s new “Dracula” are quite a few. Echoes of the sooner movie‘s imagery ring throughout a number of of Besson’s in any other case distinctive pictures, and whereas a lot of that overlap is stylistic, the 2 films’ structural comparisons additionally carry a recognizable cadence that marks Eggers the plain winner. Besson takes actual liberties with Stoker’s unique saga too, hinting at a purposeful try to reframe Dracula as a sly romantic hero that winds up trying like simply one other ineffectual vampire film as an alternative.
Evoking the spritely mischievousness that Jones nailed in Jordan Peele’s “Get Out,” the actor’s impish efficiency because the titular bloodsucker usually performs like an prolonged audition for an additional undertaking. He’d match proper in on AMC’s “Interview with the Vampire,” and somebody ought to have his agent test to see if “28 Years Later” is hiring extra Jimmys. However these comparisons solely come to thoughts in the course of the movie as a result of Besson leaves a lot interpretive house between the supply materials and his unfastened remodeling.
As Dracula, Jones is giddy and joyous with flecks of depravity bursting by because the plot expands to incorporate his ethereal bond with Harker’s fiancée, Mina Murray (additionally Bleu). Holding viewers by the throat for a handful of robust beats, even because the script slips by all the solid’s fingers, the devilish actor sells Besson’s interpretation on charisma and crafty. You earnestly consider within the love between the embattled prince and his princess, and watching Dracula seduce Mina in a super-saturated wonderland evocative of “Moulin Rouge!,” you purchase that these second-generation soulmates might have severely reincarnated their connection. However when digital gargoyles begin flying down from the ceiling, the horror-motion mechanics Besson can’t assist however embrace right here overwhelm no matter intimacy his movie had earlier than.
A finale that’s meant to take an intoxicating love story and make it an explosive combat to the end turns into sincerely foolish, and the erotic cost by no means fairly comes again for Jones and his scene accomplice, Bleu. Their ardour can’t catch, and regardless of fun-enough moments of bloodletting and corpse counting, Besson’s “Dracula” hardly ever if ever feels scary. The filmmaker leans pop-comic reasonably than petrifying in his last draft, choosing earnestness that smothers atmospheric dread. That tonal selection may need labored with a extra charming ensemble, however because it stands, this imaginative and prescient by no means totally clicks into place.
Notably, Christoph Waltz seems as a maddeningly nonplussed priest tasked with searching the titular vampire. He presents mental conversations about God, the Satan, and ethical ambiguity that tease at thematic depth. And but, Waltz’s affable, picket interpretation flattens the function and makes the film’s ethical heart learn as oddly mundane. Operating greater than two hours, “Dracula” in the end ignores the recognizable rhythms that make love tales and monster films compelling — forcing audiences to stew in a historic dramedy that depends on flimsy humor to patch over too many technical issues.
The solid’s deliveries on Besson’s punchlines are robust, and editor Lucas Fabiani retains up his finish of the deal relating to timing. However not even Jones isn’t humorous or magnetic sufficient to maintain consideration with out the help of actual suspense and attract. Immortality isn’t the identical factor as relevance, and for American audiences, Besson’s “Dracula” is a high-quality excuse to go to the theaters however hardly a seductive one. With greater than 200 “Dracula” movies already in circulation, the style feels prepared to offer each a relaxation.
Grade: C-
From Vertical within the U.S. on February 6, “Dracula” is now in theaters.
Need to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie critiques and demanding ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched publication, In Overview by David Ehrlich, by which our Chief Movie Critic and Head Evaluations Editor rounds up the most effective new critiques and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely accessible to subscribers.