The watch for Amy Adams to regain her glowing 2010’s kind goes on in “On the Sea”, a woozy, heavy-lidded melodrama from Hungarian director Kornél Mundruczowith a screenplay by his companion Kata Wéber. Derived from Wéber’s private experiences, it follows the trajectory of a breakdown precipitated by a midlife disaster: its prehistory and the shattering central occasion, after which the acknowledgement of it, and gradual hopes of restoration. Mundruczó and editor David Jancsó relate the occasions linearly, honing in on Adams’ character’s gradual readmission to her previous life, with snatches of quick-cut, wordless fragments offering swift, if imprecise, exposition of the previous.
Each bit of the movie’s intricate building is simply too lopsided: the movie’s narrative timeline provides a very closed-off sense of this chapter in her restoration; the eventual explanations are too cursory, generally struggling to persuade on the severity of what’s occurred; and Adams, if not miscast, can’t discover essentially the most charismatic register in her efficiency vary to hold it on her shoulders.
Going down on the monied and sedate Massachusetts shoreline, after its predecessor “Items of a Lady” opted for inner-city Boston grit, the setting additionally generates the movie’s deflated feeling, and slots what could possibly be a cathartic purge for Adams’ character Laura Baum, an eminent dance choreographer, into an array of different characters’ first world issues. We first glimpse her being discharged from an upscale rehab clinic, the actress providing one in all her tarter line readings as she hopes by no means to see the guide physician once more, ought to the therapy proves profitable. However, while being launched to her fast household, we uncover the “lengthy sabbatical in Bali” cowl story — a proof for the time-out to her circle of mates and colleagues.
Suspicious of her mild-mannered husband Martin (Murray Bartlett), a gifted however under-recognized figurative painter, each for his lack of day-to-day belief in her, and the likelihood he was untrue in her absence, a key motivation of Laura’s is re-establishing a wholesome proximity to her two youngsters: the college-bound Josie (Chloe East), and pre-teen Felix (Redding Munsell). Her angle concerning the former has an air of jealousy, with the sexual experimentation and partying she enjoys within the sun-kissed milieu making her fear she gained’t reinvigorate her personal, mature life. Merely, she must re-articulate her honest love and attachment, conscious how she couldn’t convey it beforehand. As Josie snaps again late within the movie, “Don’t fear about how I’m. You spent your entire life worrying about how you’re.”
Her relationship with Felix, nonetheless solely a child, is most consequential as to why the breakdown occurred, and her later inpatient care. Within the sole sequence the place Mundruczó is ready to summon actual dramatic rigidity, Laura takes him to the seashore, the place regardless of their warning and consciousness of the hazard, Felix is stung by a swarm of beached jellyfish, requiring a routine hospital journey – an echo of the breakdown’s key inciting incident, which the movie lastly unveils at this level. While her son recovers within the ward, Laura has a chat over some French fries with a useful, and romantically promising stranger named Keegan (Brett Goldstein), whose gig as a kite salesman we glimpse, with a air of twee symbolism, earlier than they stepped earlier onto the seashore.
This kite motif is an effective segue into discussing Mundruczó’s personal authorial perspective, and his varied, generally hanging, visible and tonal selections. In a slight echo of “TÁR” (which is commanding a lot affect in 2020s cinema), Laura has assumed management of her influential, troubled late father’s dance firm, whose brilliance additionally dovetailed with abusive habits in the direction of his forged. Laura’s existential disaster hinges on if resigning from it would empower her, however with its New York cultural eminence, there’s an entire firm of workers ready to work once more, coupled together with her function because the household breadwinner. Although we always remember the body of Laura’s private journey, the second half of “On the Sea” considerations the destiny of what on earth will occur to the skeletally rendered firm, with the boardroom intrigue transposed to a flashy beach-side feast. Critic David Edelstein (who’s intriguingly credited on the movie’s story) makes a cameo as a lofty but principled artwork critic at one desk, the subplot’s welcome be aware of self-awareness and mischief.
The Hungarian nationwide cinema the place Mundruczó began is thought for its lengthy, choreographed takes, usually achieved by steadicam, and that’s maintained for dialogue protection right here, though not with the dynamism of “Items of a Lady.” Far much less persuasive are the makes use of of spontaneous fashionable dance sequences, whether or not within the flashback montages, or when Josie instantly dances forcefully first to spite her mom while arguing in her studio, and later in a reconciliation scene. It’s clearly meant to to be a terrific flourish of troubling absurdity, however scans as goofy. Certainly, the title “On the Sea” solidly encompasses Laura’s existential state, however altering it to “all at sea” doubles as a harsh description on the movie itself.
Grade: C
“On the Sea” premiered on the 2026 Berlin Movie Pageant. It’s at present in search of U.S. distribution.
Wish to keep updated on IndieWire’s movie critiques and important ideas? Subscribe right here to our newly launched e-newsletter, In Assessment by David Ehrlich, wherein our Chief Movie Critic and Head Critiques Editor rounds up the very best new critiques and streaming picks together with some unique musings — all solely accessible to subscribers.